How Creative Choices Can Make or Break Your Ad Campaign

How Creative Choices Can Make or Break Your Ad Campaign
Brittany Rohr, founder and CEO of Rohring Results, showcasing expertise in local SEO for small businesses in Orlando.
Brittany Rohr

Founder and CEO

How Creative Choices Can Make or Break Your Ad Campaign

This case study explored how different types of Facebook ad creatives (video vs. image) affect audience engagement across various industries. The findings reveal that the effectiveness of ad formats largely depends on the audience and the type of product or service being promoted.

+929.39%

Users

+897.97%

Sessions

+1,148.32%

Engaged Sessions

Challenge

The challenge in Facebook Ads lies in ensuring that the right creative format effectively engages the target audience. Many advertisers struggle with low engagement and poor performance when using a one-size-fits-all approach. Specifically:

  • Retail campaigns often have trouble engaging younger audiences, especially when using static image ads that don’t capture attention as well as dynamic content.
  • Sports campaigns face similar issues, with image ads failing to connect with younger, active demographics, particularly during promotional periods.
  • Service-based businesses (such as cleaning and roofing) struggle with low engagement from younger people and need to adjust their approach to better reach older adults, who are more likely to need their services.

Solution

The solution was to experiment with different ad creative formats and tailor them to the specific audience of each client. Here’s how we addressed the problem:

  • A/B Testing: We tested video carousels and image ads to see which formats worked best for different target groups.
  • Target Audience Segmentation: For younger audiences (18-34), we used video carousel ads, as they tend to engage more with dynamic, motion-based content. For older audiences (55+), we used single image ads, which performed better with that demographic.
  • Campaign Optimization: We fine-tuned the creative choices based on the campaign goals and the specific needs of each industry—retail, sports, and services (cleaning and roofing).

This strategy allowed us to match the right ad format to the right audience, leading to better engagement, reduced cost per conversion, and overall improved performance for each client.

Video Carousel Ads

  • Most effective with younger audiences (25–34), especially women, who were highly engaged.
  • Video ads tend to resonate with this group because younger people are more attracted to dynamic, motion-based content.
  • Older demographics (45+) showed minimal engagement with video ads, confirming that video is best for younger users.

Single Image Ads (Sports Campaign)

Audience Insights for Single Image Ads (Sports Ad Campaign)
  • Older demographics (65+) responded much better to single image ads compared to younger groups.
  • The campaign struggled with younger audiences (25-54), and the high cost per result showed that single image ads were less cost-effective for this audience, especially for active sports buyers.

Image Ads (Holiday Shopping)

Audience Insights for Image Ads Image Ads (Holiday Season Shopping Specials)
  • These ads performed best with older shoppers (55+), especially during holiday promotions, where quick, visual decision-making is key.
  • Younger audiences (18–34) showed little engagement, confirming that static image ads are less effective for younger shoppers.
  • Image ads were cost-effective for older demographics during seasonal promotions.

Video Ads (Cleaning Company Campaign)

  • Unlike typical video campaigns targeting younger people, this ad performed well with older adults (55–64, 65+), likely because they are more interested in practical services like cleaning.
  • The video ads showed low cost per result, especially for women, indicating strong cost efficiency in this demographic.

Video Ads (Roofing Campaign)

Audience Insights for Video Ads (Roofing Company Campaign)
  • Older homeowners (65+ and 35–44) had the highest engagement, indicating that roofing services are most relevant to mid-to-older adults.
  • The gender split was balanced (50% men, 50% women), suggesting that both genders are equally involved in home maintenance decisions.
  • Younger audiences (18–34) showed minimal engagement, confirming that roofing services are primarily needed by older adults.

Conclusion

This case study demonstrates that success in Facebook advertising isn’t just about budget or reach—it’s about making the right creative choices for the right audience. By tailoring ad formats to specific demographics and industries, each campaign achieved stronger engagement, better cost efficiency, and higher conversions. The key takeaway? Data-driven creativity is what separates average campaigns from exceptional ones.

If your Facebook ads aren’t delivering the results you want, we can help refine your creative strategy. Schedule a discovery call with Rohring Results today and learn how we can design and optimize ad campaigns that captivate your audience and drive measurable growth.

You might also enjoy

6 Years, One Monitor What Google's Ad Tech Antitrust Ruling Means for Advertisers
Industry Impact

What Google’s Ad Tech Antitrust Ruling Means for Advertisers

A federal judge just decided how much Google has to change the way it runs online advertising. The answer: less than the government wanted, but more than nothing.  What Happened  On September 2, US District Judge Leonie Brinkema rejected the Justice Department’s request to force Google to sell off parts of its ad tech business.

Read More »
80 Fewer Views Why Reach Is Shrinking Everywhere
Market Update

31% Fewer Views: Why Reach Is Shrinking Everywhere

Post the same kind of content today that performed well a year ago, and it likely reaches fewer people. That is not a platform glitch. It is math. There is a lot more content competing for the same amount of attention.  What the Data Shows According to Metricool’s 2026 platform data, Instagram views were up

Read More »
Rohring Results
Scroll to Top