As more brands use AI in marketing, many are starting to realize that speed and efficiency are not enough. Creating more content faster only works if the message still connects with people. Without strong human input, campaigns can quickly feel off or out of touch.
A recent example is McDonald’s Netherlands holiday campaign. The brand used AI to help create a Christmas ad, but the message did not land well with audiences. The backlash shows how AI-driven marketing can fall short when strategy and human judgment are not guiding the process, and it highlights a growing challenge for businesses relying on AI for creative decisions.
McDonald’s AI Christmas Campaign
McDonald’s Netherlands launched an AI-assisted holiday ad to stand out during the busy Christmas season. The 45-second video, called “The Most Terrible Time of the Year,” was based on the classic song “It’s the Most Wonderful Time of the Year.”
Instead of showing happy holiday moments, the ad focused on common frustrations. It showed people dealing with stressful travel, awkward situations, and everyday problems, while a rewritten version of the song played in the background.
The idea was meant to be relatable, but it did not connect with viewers. Many people felt the ad was too negative and did not match the usual holiday feeling of warmth and joy.
The backlash was immediate.
Consumers said the ad felt:
- Tone-deaf
- Emotionally disconnected
- Out of sync with the season
Within days, the ad was pulled.
What Went Wrong
This wasn’t simply a “bad ad.” It was a decision problem that AI helped scale faster.
- AI Scaled the Wrong Idea Faster
AI did not create the mistake, but it helped push it forward quickly.
The campaign moved ahead without properly checking the message or how people might react. A stronger review process could have caught the issue early.
AI made it easier to execute—but didn’t make it better.
- The Message Missed Emotionally
Holiday marketing needs to feel warm, positive, and relatable.
This campaign did the opposite. It focused on stress and frustration, which did not match what people expect during the holidays.
AI cannot fully understand emotions or context, so human input is critical here.
- Brand Expectations Were Ignored
McDonald’s is known for being:
- Familiar
- Comforting
- Positive
This campaign felt negative and out of place. That disconnect is what caused people to react so strongly.
Business & Brand Impact
Even though the campaign was pulled quickly, the damage was still real:
- Money was wasted on production and ads
- Brand perception took a hit
- More attention was placed on the risks of AI in marketing
Most importantly, it shows a bigger issue; AI can scale mistakes just as fast as it scales good ideas.
Industry Implications
This is not a one-time issue. As more brands adopt AI in their marketing, similar challenges are becoming more common, especially when there is not enough human oversight. Many campaigns are starting to show the same patterns, including:
- Content that feels generic
- Messaging that misses the mark
- Lower-quality creative
- Growing distrust among audiences
At the same time, there is a clear shift happening in how businesses approach AI. Early adoption focused heavily on efficiency and scale, but priorities are changing as risks become more visible.
Before, AI was mainly used for:
- Speed
- Lower costs
- More content
Now, the focus is shifting toward:
- Trust
- Brand safety
- Quality
- Human oversight
What Marketers Should Do
AI is a powerful tool, but it requires the right structure and oversight to deliver real value. Marketers need to focus on using AI in a way that strengthens strategy, not replaces it. The following principles help ensure AI supports performance without creating unnecessary risk.
Keep Humans in Control
AI should be used to support execution, not to lead creative or strategic decisions. Human input is essential for setting direction, defining tone, and ensuring campaigns align with brand values and audience expectations.
Add Strong Review Steps
AI-generated content should never go live without proper evaluation. Marketers need clear review processes in place to ensure quality and alignment, including checks for:
- Brand consistency
- Tone and messaging accuracy
- Likely audience response
Test the Message Before Launch
Before launching any campaign, messaging should be pressure-tested in context. This helps catch potential issues early and ensures the content connects as intended. Key questions to ask include:
- Does this feel appropriate for the current moment?
- Does this reflect our brand voice?
- Could this be misunderstood or taken negatively?
Prioritize Brand Trust Over Speed
While AI can improve efficiency, speed should not come at the expense of trust. Protecting brand reputation and maintaining credibility should always take priority over saving time or reducing costs.
The Bottom Line
The McDonald’s campaign shows that AI is not the problem; poor strategy is. While AI can help brands move faster and produce more content, it does not improve judgment, messaging, or creativity on its own. Without strong human oversight, it can quickly amplify the wrong ideas and lead to costly mistakes.
The brands that succeed will be the ones that use AI as a support tool while keeping strategy and decision-making human-led. At Rohring Results, we help businesses do exactly that by combining AI efficiency with clear strategy, strong messaging, and a focus on long-term brand trust. If you are using AI in your marketing, now is the time to make sure you are doing it right. Schedule a discovery call to get started!



